Francine Shapiro Library

Choose any combination of the search options below. If you do not wish to include an option in your search, leave the box blank, or select "Any."


 Your Results - you searched for the keyword Critique 18 Results    

  Sort Results By:

1. Follette, W. C., & Beitz, K. (2003, July). Adding a more rigorous scientific agenda to the empirically supported treatment movement. Behavior Modification, 27(3), 369-386. doi:10.1177/0145445503027003006.

Language: English

Format: Journal

Abstract:
As the empirically supported treatment (EST) effort has expanded, there are efforts to make the study of ESTs a more integral part of training programs. In its present form, the EST list provides a poor model of how to evaluate treatment and scientific issues related to our field. This article offers several suggestions regarding how to establish a more relevant scientific agenda for the committee’swork if the study of ESTs is to usefully influence training programs. Recommendations are made to encourage programs and the CSP to study mechanisms of change, important contextual variables for therapy delivery, the distinction between statistical significance and clinical meaningfulness, dissemination, cost-effectiveness, and iatrogenic effects. It is argued that any program that created a curriculum educating students to thoughtfully address these issues when evaluating therapies would be producing sound clinical scientists regardless of the quality of the EST list itself.

Keywords: Critique  Training  Committee on Science and Practice  CSP  Empirically Supported Treatments  EST  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

2. Allen, J., & Lewis, L. (1996, Spring). A conceptual framework for treating traumatic memories and its application to EMDR. Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic, 60(2), 238-263.

Language: English

Format: Journal

Abstract:
With burgeoning interest in trauma has come a proliferation of interventions for the treatment of intrusive memories. At this stage of development, uniformity of clinical practice in the trauma field is neither possible nor desirable. The literature suggests that a wide range of treatment interventions are effective. But diversity in practice does not preclude coherence in conceptualization. This article presents a general theoretical framework to provide clinicians and patients with a rationale for treating intrusive symptoms of PTSD. To illustrate the applicability of the framework, the authors critique Shapiro's recent theoretical explanation of Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR), an exemplary cognitive-behavioral approach to the treatment of trauma. EMDR merits careful theoretical reappraisal, because it has become a highly popular and seemingly effective technique that currently rests on an unsound neurobiological theoretical foundation. [Author Abstract]

Keywords: Hallucinations  Intrusive Thoughts Memory Impairment  Neurophysiology  Professional Criticism  Psychotherapeutic Processes  PTSD  Treatment Effectiveness  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

3. Spates, C. R., Waller, S., & Koch, E. I. (2000, Summer). A critique of Lohr et al's (1998) review of EMDR and Lipke's commentary: Of messages and messengers. the Behavior Therapist, 23(7), 148-154.

Language: English

Format: Newsletter

Abstract:
Our goals are as follows: (a) to propose what we believe is a reasonable context within which to evaluate data pertinent to EMDR; (b) to examine how the evidence fits within an evaluation of the more general treatment outcome literature on PTSD; (c) to suggest a constructive direction for future research. [Adapted from Text, p. 148] A comment on: Jeffrey M. Lohr, David F. Tolin, and Scott O. Lilienfeld, "Efficacy of eye movement desensitization and reprocessing: implications for behavior therapy", Behavior Therapy 29(1): 123-156 (Winter 1998) [20817] and Howard J. Lipke, "Comments on 'Thirty years of behavior therapy..." and the promise of the application of scientific principles", Behavior Therapist 22: 11-14 (1999).

Keywords: Methodology  Posttraumatic Stress Disorder  Professional Criticism  PTSD  Treatment Effectiveness  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

4. Cloitre, M. (2009, January). Effective psychotherapies for posttraumatic stress disorder: A review and critique. CNS Spectrums, 14(1, Supplement 1), 32-43 .

Language: English

Format: Journal

Abstract:
This report reviews and critiques the psychotherapy literature for the treatment of PTSD and systematically presents data on sample size, rates of completion, and effect sizes. Substantial progress has been made in the use of cognitive behavioral therapies and eye movement desensitization and reprocessing for the resolution of PTSD. Innovations in PTSD treatments are identified. Further advances are needed in the treatment of populations with complex and chronic forms of PTSD such as those found in childhood abuse populations, refugee populations, and those experiencing chronic mental illness. The need to address comorbid emotional, social, and physical health consequences of trauma, to implement treatments in community-based settings, and to incorporate larger systems of care into study designs is noted. [Author Abstract]

Keywords: Cognitive Therapy  Exposure Therapy  Literature Review  Posttraumatic Stress Disorder  Psychotherapy  PTSD  Stressors  Survivors  Treatment Effectiveness  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

5. Wachtel, P. L. (2002). EMDR and psychoanalysis. In F. Shapiro (Ed.), EMDR as an integrative psychotherapy approach: Experts of diverse orientations explore the paradigm prism (1st ed.) (pp. 123-150). Washington: American Psychological Association.

Language: English

Format: Book Section

Abstract:
Although EMDR is clearly an integrative approach, it is an integrative approach with a strong cognitive-behavioral flavor. In this chapter, EMDR is examined and considered from a different vantage point. For some time, I too have been engaged in developing an integrative approach to therapy. However, apropos the previous paragraph, my integrative efforts have a different flavor; they are rooted most deeply in the psychodynamic tradition, not the cognitive- behavioral.As a consequence of my psychodynamic vantage point, my view and use of EMDR differ somewhat from the "classic" approach to EMDR. This chapter is thus likely to reflect clinical and theoretical views that differ in important ways from those of many of this book's other authors. However, my discussion does not constitute a critique of EMDR. I began using EMDR and am writing this chapter because I am intrigued by EMDR -- by its clinical potential, the experiences it seems to generate, and the challenges to theory and research that it presents. My goal is to expand our ways of viewing and thinking about EMDR, and to consider the ways in which EMDR can be enriched by a psychoanalytic perspective and vice versa. For an integration or combination of EMDR and psychoanalysis to be viable, two conditions must be satisfied. The differences must not be so fundamental and unbridgeable that any effort to bring the two approaches together is inherently incoherent and contradictory. At the same time, the differences must not be so trivial or superficial that putting them together adds little or nothing. The interface between EMDR and psychoanalysis meets both these conditions, and the chapter will attempt to demonstrate this as it proceeds. [Adapted from Text, p. 124] [Pilots]

Keywords: Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy  Psychotherapeutic Processes  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

6. Ferrie, R. (2013, May). EMDR therapy and psychiatric medication. Presentation at the annual EMDR Canada Conference, Banff, Alberta CAN.

Language: English

Format: Conference

Abstract:
Many clients who present for EMDR are medicated with psychiatric drugs. The question arises whether these medications are helpful in the context of EMDR therapy or not. We as psychotherapists, by definition, are involved in a dialogue about mental health with our clients; therefore, on the important subject of psychoactive medication we have a responsibility to be informed ourselves and to share this information with our clients. This presentation is intended to provide tools especially for the non-medical therapist to learn how to navigate the territory of psychiatric drugs-use in a way that helps clients. Included in the presentation will be a discussion of individual case studies of traumatized clients, who had first been treated with psychiatric medication and then sought EMDR therapy; an examination of how psychiatric drugs help or hinder and how they compare to the EMDR therapy approach; and evidence from the current literature which calls into question the assumption of mental disorders being due to a chemical imbalance requiring life-long medication. The robustness of the EMDR protocol and how helpful it has proven to be to clients who have dealt with being heavily medicated and suffering from attendant side effects will be illustrated. Learning objectives: • Critique the evidence-based literature on psychiatric medication and the now insupportable information, given to clients and doctors, which excludes the findings of long-term harm caused by all classes of psychiatric medication. Participants will be able to assess the importance of the few reliable long-term outcome studies and compare the effectiveness of psychotherapy/EMDR with psychiatric drugs. • Evaluate a series of cases studies of clients, previously traumatized, who were medicated with psychoactive drugs when first seeking EMDR Therapy. • Gain knowledge of the different available protocols designed to help clients to be safely weaned off psychiatric medication. • In the process of discussion, participants will compare their own and other participants’ experiences with such medicated clients.

Keywords: Medication  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

7. Herbert, J. D., & Mueser, K. T. (1992, September). Eye movement desensitization: A critique of the evidence. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 23(3), 169-174. doi:10.1016/0005-7916(92)90033-F.

Language: English

Format: Journal

Abstract:
The scientific evidence supporting the efficacy of eye movement desensitization (EMD), a novel intervention for traumatic memories and related conditions, is reviewed. The sparse research conducted in this area has serious methodological flaws, precluding definite conclusions regarding the effectiveness of the procedure. Clinicians are cautioned against uncritically accepting the clinical efficacy of EMD. [Author Summary]

Keywords: Literature Review  Treatment Effectiveness  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

8. Lohr, J., Tolin, D., & Lilienfeld, S. (2000, Summer). Final comments on Lipke's critique of Lohr, Tolin, and Lilienfeld (1998). the Behavior Therapist, 23(7), 145-147.

Language: English

Format: Newsletter

Abstract:
Responds to H. Lipke's critique of J. Lohr, D. Tolin, and S. Lilienfeld's study which reviews 17 studies on the effectiveness of eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) and the conceptual analysis of its mechanisms of action. The authors address a number of issues from Lipke's critique, including the assertion that EMDR is more efficacious or effective than extant behavioral treatments. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2008 APA, all rights reserved)

Keywords: Anxiety Disorders  Behavior Therapy  Emotional Trauma  Memory  Posttraumatic Stress Disorder  PTSD  Traumatic Memories  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

9. Edmond, T. (2005, September). The future of evidence in EMDR. Plenary presented at the annual meeting of the EMDR International Association, Seattle, WA.

Language: English

Format: Conference

Abstract:
Evidence based practice has gained increased attention in recent years, having been advanced initially by the medical professions, encouraged by various academic institutions, increasingly required by insurance companies, and endorsed by many professional associations. Although this represents an important movement towards improving the quality of care available to clients, there are legitimate concerns about what constitutes evidence. In the past 15 years, research on EMDR has proliferated and the methodological rigor of that work has greatly improved. Yet skepticism ahout the effectiveness of EMDR remains and much is still unknown about the parameters of this innovative approach to psychotherapy. This presentation will provide a description of evidence based practice as a backdrop for examining the current state of EMDR research with recommendations for areas of research that are needed, methodological issues that should be considered, and the role of practitioners in the generation of that knowledge. Findings from a mix-methods study evaluating the effectiveness of EMDR with adult female survivors of childhood sexual abuse will be used as an example to critique the limitations of the gold standard approach to generating evidence based practice and to illustrate the importance of methodological diversity in the pursuit of knowledge about the practice of psychotherapy.

Keywords: Evidence-Based Practice  Gold Standard  Plenary  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

10. Gilson, S., & Foisson, P. (2005). L'EMDR science ou croyance? Une revue critique de la littérature [EMDR science or faith? A critical review of the literature EMDR science or belief?]. Acta Psychiatrica Belgica, 105(1), 47-58.

Language: French

Format: Journal

Abstract:
L'« Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing » (EMDR) est une intervention thérapeutique controversée utilisée essentiellement dans le traitement des syndromes de stress post traumatiques (PTSD). Cet article a pour objectif de passer en revue la littérature scientifique afin d'évaluer l'état des connaissances actuelles quant à l'efficacité et la spécificité de la technique et de pouvoir éventuellement envisager d'autres champs de recherche. Le nombre et la qualité scientifique des études sont encore insuffisants. Leurs conclusions contradictoires ne permettent pas de valider l'EMDR comme une technique efficace et spécifique dans le traitement du PTSD ou d'autres pathologies. Néanmoins, certains résultats positifs, la rapidité d'action et le faible coût de la technique justifient de plus amples recherches.

The "Eye Movement and Desensitizer Reprocessing (EMDR) is a controversial therapeutic intervention used primarily in the treatment of post traumatic stress syndrome (PTSD). This article aims to review the scientific literature to assess the state of current knowledge regarding the effectiveness and specificity of the technique and to possibly explore other fields of research. The number and quality of scientific studies are still insufficient. Their contradictory findings do not validate EMDR as an effective technical and specific in the treatment of PTSD or other disorders. Nevertheless, some positive results, speed of action and the low cost of technology warrant further investigation.

Keywords: Review  Posttraumatic Stress Disorder  PSTD  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

11. Sack, M., Lempa, W., & Lamprecht, F. (2001, September-Oktober). Meta-analyse von studien über EMDR - Behandlung von patienten last mitposttraumatischen störungen: Der einfluss der studienqualität auf effektstärken [Study quality and effect-sizes: A meta-analysis of EMDR-treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder]. Psychotherapie, Psychosomatik, Medizinische Psychologie, 51 (9-10), 350-355. doi:10.1055/s-2001-16898.

Language: German

Format: Journal

Abstract:
Obwohl die Wirksamkeit von Augenbewegungen Desensitizer gute und Wiederaufbereitung (EMDR) in der Behandlung von Patienten mit PTSD ist bis heute eine Reihe von Studien dokumentiert, ist diese neue Technik noch die Behandlung der höchst umstrittene kritischen Ziel. Unsere Meta-Analyse versucht, die Frage, ob EMDR-Therapie-Studien mit hohen Qualitätsstandards zu beantworten, erzielen Sie bessere Ergebnisse als andere. Dafür werden alle veröffentlichten Studien ein Verfahren der Scoring-Studie die Qualität und Wirkung Größen berechnet unterzogen wurden. Es kann sehr sorgfältig geplante Studien gezeigt werden, einschließlich der Behandlung von gut ausgebildeten Therapeuten und mit einer hohen Anzahl von ausreichend Behandlungen im Vergleich zur Erzielung besserer Ergebnisse Methodische Studien mit niedrigen Standards. [Abstract Autor]

Although the efficacy of eye movement desensitization good and reprocessing (EMDR) in the treatment of patients with PTSD is up to now documented by a number of studies, this new treatment technique is still the target of highly controversial critique. Our meta-analysis tries to answer the question of Whether EMDR-therapy studies with higher quality standards, achieve better results than others. Therefore, all published studies underwent a scoring procedure of study quality and effect sizes were computed. It can be shown that carefully planned studies, including treatment by well-trained therapists and with a Sufficiently high number of treatment sessions, achieve better results compared to studies with low methodological standards. [Author Abstract]

Keywords: Meta Analysis  Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, PTSD, Treatment Effectiveness  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

12. Lohr, J. M., Kleinknecht, R. A., Conley, A. T., Dal Cerro, S., Schmidt, S., & Sonntag, M. E. (1992, September). A methodological critique of the current status of eye movement desensitization (EMD). Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 23(3), 159-167. doi:10.1016/0005-7916(92)90032-E.

Language: English

Format: Journal

Abstract:
Eye Movement Desensitization (EMD) has been recently advocated as a rapid treatment for the elimination of traumatic memories responsible for the maintenance of a number of anxiety disorders and their clinical correlates. Despite a limited conceptual framework, EMD has attracted considerable interest among clinicians and researchers. The popularity and interest generated by EMD will likely result in wide usage. We present a methodological critique of it with reference to assessment, treatment outcome, and treatment process. We also provide guidelines for judging the methodological adequacy of research on EMD and suggest intensive research to assess effectiveness, treatment components, and comparisons with other procedures. [Author Summary]

Keywords: PTSD Assessment Instruments  Literature Review  Methodology  Posttraumatic Stress Disorder  PTSD  Research Needs  Review  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

13. McNally, R. J. (1999, November-December). On eye movements and animal magnetism: A reply to Greenwald's defense of EMDR. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 13(6), 617-620. doi:10.1016/S0887-6185(99)00020-1.

Language: English

Format: Journal

Abstract:
In his commentary on my article comparing Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) with animal magnetism therapy, Greenwald (this issue) expresses several criticisms. Unable to refute a single factual statement, he resorts to attacking my rhetorical style. The purpose of this reply is to rebut his critique. [Author Abstract]

Keywords: Franz Anton  Mesmer  Professional Criticism Reply  Psychotherapy  Treatment Effectiveness  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

14. Blake, D. D., & Sonnenberg, R. T. (1998). Outcome research on behavioral and cognitive-behavioral treatments for trauma survivors. In V. M. Follette, J. I. Ruze & F. R. Abueg (Eds.), Cognitive-behavioral therapies for trauma (pp. 15-47), New York: Guilford Press.

Language: English

Format: Book Section

Abstract:
In this chapter, we describe the current status of outcome research on behavioral and cognitive-behavioral therapy for PTSD. In this endeavor, we describe these treatments and outline their empirical foundations, providing rationale for their use. We then review and critique the existing research and propose future directions for outcome research. [Text, p. 42]

Keywords: Americans  Behavior Therapy  Child Abuse  Cognitive Therapy  Females  Males  Posttraumatic Stress Disorder  PTSD  Rape  Survivors  Treatment Effectiveness  Veterans  Vietnam War  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

15. Hopper, J. W., & van der Kolk, B. A. (2001). Retrieving, assessing, and classifying traumatic memories:  A preliminary report on three case studies of a new standardized method. Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment and Trauma, 4(2), 33-71. doi:10.1300/J146v04n02_03.

Language: English

Format: Journal

Abstract:
The study of traumatic memories is still an emerging field, both methodologically and theoretically. Previous questionnaire and interview methods for studying traumatic memories have been limited in their ability to evoke and assess remembrances with the characteristics long observed by clinicians. In this article, we introduce a new standardized method that incorporates a laboratory procedure for retrieving memories of traumatic events and a clinically informed measure for assessing these memories' characteristics. We present three case studies to demonstrate the data yielded by script-driven remembering and the Traumatic Memory Inventory - Post-Script Version (TMI-PS). We then discuss subjects' script-driven remembrances in terms of methodology, theoretical classification of traumatic memories, and the interplay between the two. Finally, we critique our method in detail and offer suggestions for future research. If validated as a method for evoking and assessing traumatic memories, and shown to yield reliable data, this integrative method shows great promise for advancing both clinical and cognitive research on traumatic memories. [Author Summary]

Keywords: Adults  Brain Imaging  Interview Schedules  Memory Impairment  Memory Retrieval Techniques  PTSD Assessment Instruments  Stressors  Survivors  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

16. Arnold, L. (1995). Some nontraditional (unconventional and/or innovative) psychosocial treatment for children and adolescents:  Critique and proposed screening principles. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 23(1), 125-140. doi:10.1007/BF01447048 .

Language: English

Format: Journal

Abstract:
Five examples of nontraditional psychosocial treatments used for children/adolescents are reviewed: eye movement desensitization and reprocessing, electroencephalographic (EEG) biofeedback, deep pressure/touch therapies, stress-challenge treatments, and confrontational scare treatments. The generic recommendations from the September 1992 National Institutes of Health Conference on Unconventional Medical Treatments are summarized. Additional screening principles specific for psychosocial treatments are proposed and applied to the five treatments. The screens do not validate treatment efficacy or evaluate the quality of any previous research, but only facilitate decisions as to whether treatments deserve controlled investigation. Scientific evaluation of the nontraditional treatments reviewed could in general benefit from blinds (at least for assessment); control conditions matched for intensity, frequency, and duration (double blind where feasible); dose-response studies; testing of generalization and endurance supplements or boosters for quick, cheap treatments with time- or domain-limited effects; and comparing cost-effectiveness with established treatments. Two unscientific pitfalls must be avoided: embracing new treatments uncritically and rejecting them without fair examination. These pitfalls must be skirted without dissipating scarce research resources. [Author Abstract]

Keywords: Adolescents  Adventure Therapy  Aversion Therapy  Biofeedback Training  Body Psychotherapy  Children  Literature Review  Research Needs  Treatment Effectiveness  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

17. Ferrie, R. K. (2006, September). Transforming imagery in the treatment of complex PTSD. Presentation at the annual meeting of the EMDR International Association, Philadelphia, PA.

Language: English

Format: Conference

Abstract:
Many trauma therapies, including EMDR, rely on the transformation of traumatic imagery to images of self-empowerment and safety, either spontaneously or by design. When traumatic memories resolve by transformation, many of the same areas of the brain are involved, as in the original perception: the brain revisits the scene and has a second chance to "see" it a different way i.e. to reprocess the memory. This workshop will begin by examining the neuroscience supporting this hypothesis. Fortunately, not only is mental imagery central to trauma therapy, facility with mental imagery is a set of skills, which can be learned by clients. Participants will be introduced to a method of teaching mental imagery skills as part of no overall resource development protocol the presenter has used in a single-case design study of Complex PTSD. This study examines the correlation between the client's degeee of facility with mental imagery and subsequent recovery from the symptoms of Complex PTSD. The method and results of this study will be presented. Client material will be used to illustrate these techniques and their application to EMDR therapy. Participants will be able to critique this study as well, and in the process, will learn how to apply the single case design paradigm to their own practices.

Keywords: Complex Posttraumatic Stress Disorder  Complex PTSD  C-PTSD  Mental Imagery  

Accuracy Verified: Yes

18. Brown, P. A. (2012). Trauma research and treatment of combat veterans: An evidence-based integrative literature review. California Institute of Integral Studies, San Francisco, CA.

Language: English

Format: Dissertation/Thesis

Abstract:
The mainstream treatments for Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) are Cognitive Behavioral and Prolonged Exposure Therapies (CBT & PE). These closely studied evidence based treatments also show high relapse, dropout, and failure rates of up to half of those treated (Bryant, R., et al., 2008, p. 555). While not as well researched and harder to measure in terms of the gold standard in Evidence Based Practice of Psychology (EBPP), studies of “alternative” treatments and their methods, yield different and interesting evidence. Using the standards espoused by EBPP alongside alternative movements, this study examined modalities used in veterans’ treatment. A guiding question was “What can the field of trauma studies learn from a systematic and comparative review of the research and treatment of combat veterans suffering the sequelae of trauma?” Included in this integrative literature review—which generates a critique and theoretical synthesis of a body of literature (Torraco, R., 2005, p. 356)—were peer-reviewed studies from 2006-2010. The participating studies consisted largely of Veterans Administration (VA)-funded, CBT/PE treatments, with an average of over 32 patients per participating study, of approximately 13 weeks duration, and where 20% of patients avoided treatment, 25% dropped out, and 30% failed treatment altogether. Concept matrix analysis of data included distillation of essential statements further reflecting poor tolerability, dropout, failure, and an inability to maintain symptom reductions (75% of studies). Authors tended to overstate positive effects while omitting adequate examination of study design and construct validity, leading to dearth bias, defined as scarcity of evidence hiding behind citations. From this integrative review of the literature a reconceptualization and agenda for future research emerged. The reconceptualization stems from the usefulness of hybridized efficacy and effectiveness research, self-reflection and bracketing, and more accounting for dearth bias. The future agenda recommends practitioners use concept matrices as iv research and practice tools, conduct more common factors research, and develop more clinical practice-based evidence. Especially as related to knowledge evaluation, increased accountability, and system-wide change, these recommendations can assist the spread of more diverse and useful EBPP, to help relieve some of the pain of the traumatized combat veteran.

Keywords: Combat Veterans  Literature Review  

Accuracy Verified: Yes